School is bad for children
John Halt
In this essay, the writer seems to be against
the idea of formal education about, he is not in favor of abolishing the school
education, and however he stands for the reformation of traditional teaching
system.
According to him, schools are killing the curiosity of the students by imposing
(forcing) the final truth in their mind. When a child comes at school he comes
with a lot of expectation and frantically he returns home with the feeling of
pessimism. Besides, the writer argues that the school has changed the students'
natural intelligence, curiosity, confidence, resourcefulness independence,
patience and energy into past, laziness, dependences, indifference. Actually
the child has got immense confidence about his potentiality but the teachers
always discourage him. The additional to this child, finds the classroom to be
cooled and ugly. There are other children but they are unable to communicate
with each other.
Most of the schools separate the learning from the living. When they create the
gap between life and learning the children are confused. The classroom
environment is artificial and the teachers act almost like robots.
Usually the students are taken as a blank sheet of paper and the teachers are
free to write on their mind. The teachers never trust the students and they
never appreciate their natural knowledge. As a result the children feel that he
is not worth of listening to.
The teachers neglect the needs for the respects of individual difference. Every
individual has got different perspective and the teachers always try to
establish the final perspective.
The teachers teach the students that to make a mistake or to be confused is to
commit a crime and as a result the students start creating the teacher. The
writer claims that the schools are teaching him to be indifferent. The class
environment is just opposite to the way how a child lives his life in a natural
form. There is no doubt that there are other children in the classroom but all
of them are in silence. They all seem as if they have nothing to do with each
others. As a result, the child takes his teachers to be inhuman.
- Reformation
According to the writer, there are fundamental
changes necessary for school education. The first and foremost thing is that
compulsory attendance should be abolished. He justifies that when something is
made compulsory it develops unwillingness from the students. It is self-evident
that forceful. Knowledge is useless at the time of crisis. Curiosity is
developed not to force but through freedom. Undoubtedly, the critics might
counter argue, “If the children did not go to school where would they go?” It
does not necessarily mean that if the children are not compelled to go to
school, they will come out in the street. When the education system is made
free, the children will be more eager to go to school.
The second reformation that the writer puts forward is that the students or the
children should be taught in a natural environment. In other words, the
teachers should bring the outer world into the school. For example, the
students should learn about the law not from the teacher but from the judging
himself.
The children should be
allowed to judge their works by themselves. It is better to encourage the
student to learn from each other rather than dictating what to the small kids
learn more readily from their teacher. They also point out the exams should be
at list and the fixed curriculum should also be abolished. His argument is that
certain hour's examination cannot judge the ability of the students. Besides
the fixed curriculum units, should be given the unlimited potentiality of the
students.
In this way John Halt stand for the reformation of the traditional system of
school education. In his opinion most of the schools are running natural
knowledge of the students and they are making them passive and dull.
In the first half in this essay John Halt criticizes formal
education and says that schools convert students natural intelligences
curiosity, confidence, resourcefulness independence ,patience and energy into
passiveness, laziness, dependences, indifferences, boredom and low self-esteem.
Halt further says that the schools discourage experimentation, creativity and
originality. - They teach students that learning in separated from living and
that students can't be trusted to learn and are no good at it. The children
from school learn that the learning is a passive process. - School neglect
students need and interest and shows no respect from individual differences -
They teach students that, “to be wrong uncertain, confused is a crime and as a
result students start to dodge, bluff, fake, cheat. - School doesn't teach to
interact with other people and to lives and without paying attention to
anything going around them. - Schools are almost always ugly, cold (not
interested) and inhuman. - They encourage dishonesty, --- and anxiety - They
provide, little opportunity for students to learn about the real world.
Halt’s recommendations to enhance real learning and improve
school
· - Abolish or modify compulsory school, attention.
· - Take students into the community to learn about real world
first hand.
· - Bring more of the real world into schools different
professional people to talk that they actually do.
· - Encourage students to work together and learn from
each other.
· - Encourage students to learn to evaluate their own work and
find their mistake and correct them.
· - Eliminate (avoid) grades, exams and rank.
· - Abolish the fixed, required curriculum.